Judge ye not

Brad Gregg

Well, there’s always the judiciary — that pesky third branch of government that makes a reasonable attempt to remain free of influence from special interest groups.

And, as everyone knows, the best way to make sure that “true justice” is carried out is to stack the deck.

The State Chamber of Oklahoma is backing a project known as the Oklahoma Civil Justice Council, that would “rate” judges on the Court of Civil Appeals and the Oklahoma Supreme Court on a zero-to-100 scale, based on expansion of liabilities and existing law.

State Rep. John Bennett, R-Sallisaw, scolded the pro-business group for taking its agenda
to the courts: “I am outraged that any group is attempting to bully the
independent judiciary here in Oklahoma. The Appellate and Supreme Court
justices have one litmus test when deciding cases: Is it
constitutional?” It’s no surprise, then, that Bennett is featured in the
State Chamber’s “2011 Most Wanted” list on account of his
“anti-business votes.”

Former State Supreme Court and Court of Appeals Judge Daniel Boudreau told Tulsa World that
while there’s nothing wrong with evaluating judges, it should be for
the right reasons, rather than whether a decision was deemed anti-business.

judiciary is there to protect the weak from the powerful, the minority
from the majority, the poor from the rich. Essentially, it protects
citizens from the excesses of government,” Boudreau said.

the weak, minority and poor from the powerful, majority and rich?
Sounds like someone hasn’t brushed up on the State Chamber’s list of
“Oklahoma Values.”

Gazette staff

This material falls under the archives category because it was imported from our previous website. It will eventually be filtered into the proper category as time allows.

Related posts



WordPress Lightbox